MIAMI HERALD
Defense Counsel Barry Coburn
questions Lt. Col. W., via closed-circuit from Carlisle Barracks at the U.S.
Army War College, during the military commissions hearing of Omar Khadr,
Saturday, May 1, 2010, at the U.S. Navy base, Guantanamo Bay, Cuba. His judge,
Army Col. Patrick Parrish, is upper right. POOL SKETCH ARTIST
May 01, 2010 5:55 PM
Changes to key Guantánamo evidence innocent, officer
says
By CAROL ROSENBERG
GUANTANAMO BAY NAVY BASE, Cuba — An
Army Special Forces officer testified Saturday that he altered a field report
to directly implicate a Canadian detainee now being held at Guantánamo in a
fatal grenade attack in Afghanistan years later because he realized that he got
it wrong and wanted to fix the historical record.
The officer denied suggestions from
defense lawyers for Omar Khadr that he changed the report at prosecutors'
urging "to make it look like Omar was guilty.”
At issue is the officer's account of
the firefight, which for years said that the terrorist who threw the grenade
that killed Army Sgt 1st Class Christopher Speer was also died in the July 2002
gunbattle near Khost, Afghanistan. Khadr, 23, is accused of murder for
allegedly hurling the grenade. He was 15 at the time.
But the officer, identified under
court rules only as Army Lt. Col. W, said he wrote that the man who threw the
grenade that killed Speer also died because he mistakenly misunderstood that
Khadr had died in the same assault as Speer.
W said he didn't realize that he got
the report wrong until some investigators preparing for Khadr's trial visited
him “a few years later.” So he opened it up on his computer and fixed it.
“The copy that was changed, adjusted
was for me, for historical purposes and that’s how you ended up with it,” the
officer said under questioning from defense attorney Barry Coburn.
W's testimony came via closed
circuit TV from the U.S. Army War College in Pennsylvania. Khadr wasn’t at the
hearing — he refused to leave his prison camp for a third straight day — and so
missed the testimony as well as seeing himself weeping in a video of his
interrogation that also screened at court Saturday.
Defense lawyers uncovered the change
in 2008. But the Special Forces officer, an assistant police chief in civilian
life, described it as completely innocent. He said he had seen the severely
wounded Khadr in native Afghan attire — he called them “man-jammies” — his
chest torn open from two shots through the back and caked with dust and
believed he’d never survive his wounds.
So, he said, he wrote a report that
assumed Khadr died.
Khadr's lawyers want a military
judge to exclude all teen's various confessions as the result of intimidation
and coercion from his very first days as a prisoner at Bagram Air Field in
Afghanistan. They argue that even subsequent friendly interrogations that
included M&M's and friendly banter with an attractive female interrogator
at Guantánamo are inadmissible under a legal theory called the fruit of the
poisoned tree.
They also argue that because he was
only 15 at the time of his capture and that he was abused while in detention he
could not voluntarily cooperate with his captors. Whether a statement was made
voluntarily is a key requirement for evidence presented to a military
commission.
Earlier Saturday, officers cleared
reporters and observers from the hearing to screen a 2003 interrogation video
that they said was classified, though it was made public by Canada's Supreme
Court two years ago and is available on YouTube. The removal of spectators came
just days after the prosecutor pledged "no secret evidence.''
The video shows the Toronto-born
teen weeping in a Guantánamo interrogation booth and pleading for help from his
Canadian interrogator. Reporters locked out of that portion of the hearing
watched the video on YouTube in a media center in a crude abandoned airport
hangar below the hilltop tribunal chamber.
The video was introduced by Khadr's
attorneys so that they could ask an agent of the Naval Criminal Investigative
Service, Jocelyn Dillard, about it. Dillard had testified that Khadr was
cooperative while she and an FBI agent interrogated him at the prison camps
hospital in 2003, once while he was receiving IV antibiotics because his year-old
war wounds were festering.
Read more here: http://www.miamiherald.com/news/nation-world/world/americas/guantanamo/article1935916.html#storylink=cpy
Operation Snatch Niggers Pt. 1
On the night of March 16, 1993 in Baladwayne, Somalia, sixteen year old
Shidane Arone sneaks into the Canadian Airborne Regiments quarters where
he was tortured and beaten to death in the hands of racist Canadian
soldiers. This remorseless act scarred the reputation of the Canadian
military in the eyes of Canadians, as well as the international
community.
No comments:
Post a Comment